Wikidata:WikiProject Media Representation/Model

Home

Model

Suggest a Test

Task Forces

Gender

Queer/LGBTQIA+

Ethnic Portrayals

Other

Non-Fiction

Format Specific

General modelling

Test results are modelled using the property assessment (P5021) with qualifier assessment outcome (P9259) in case of a pass/failure result.

assessment	Bechdel test edit assessment outcome passes 0 references add reference
		add value

If a test does not produce a pass/failure result but a score assessment outcome (P9259) is omitted and only review score (P444) is used:

assessment	<DuVernay Test> edit review score 3/5 0 references add reference
		add value

There are additional qualifiers than can be used to convey more information about the assessment outcome:

Qualifiers to use along with assessment (P5021) in addition to assessment outcome (P9259)

Qualifiers to give more exact information about the assessment.

Title	ID	Data type	Description	Examples	Inverse
review score	P444	String	assessment: used to state how many points this work scored	Point Break <assessment> Bechdel test <review score> 0/3	-
criterion used	P1013	Item	criterion: used to state which criteria were crucial to the test result	The Virgin Suicides <assessment> Landau Test <criterion used> first Landau or Reverse Landau Test criteria	-

Qualifiers to express to what extend the assessment is valid.

Title	ID	Data type	Description	Examples	Inverse
nature of statement	P5102	Item	currently mostly used with the following values: rarely (Q28962310) - If the statement is accepted to be true but it is admitted that it is hardly the case. (E.g. if a film is said to pass the Bechdel Test but two women only talk for a very short time about something else than a man.) disputed (Q18912752) - If the statement is disputed. (This may be applied to media critics, but also to the comment section of the Bechdel Test Movie List, for example) dubious (Q104378399) - If an evaluation is dubious. (I mostly introduced it for the case that one editor has doubts about the statement of another editor but there is no decision, yet. Especially with respect to the application of Feldman criteria I see a lot of potential to apply this qualifier right away (e.g. if an editor decides that there is rather no stereotyping of women but is rather unsure about one character.)).	The Pianist <assessment> Bechdel test <nature of statement> disputed	-

Modelling patterns

Bechdel test pattern: using review score (P444) in case of failure

Requirements:

• The test requires a film to pass all criteria in order to pass the test.
• The criteria build on each other (e.g. in order to pass the second criterion the first criterion has to be fulfilled)

For passing works no additional qualifier is needed:

assessment	Bechdel test edit assessment outcome passes 0 references add reference
		add value

For failing works review score (P444) may be used to express how many points exactly were scored

assessment	Big edit assessment outcome fails review score 1/3 0 references add reference
		add value

Tests following this pattern

• Bechdel test and Reverse Bechdel test
• Mako Mori test
• Waithe test
• Russ test
• Tauriel test
• Raleigh Becket test
• Vito Russo Test
• Topside Test
• Coates Test
• Shukla Test

Riz test pattern: using criterion used (P1013) in case of failure

For passing works no additional qualifier is needed:

assessment	Riz Test edit assessment outcome passes 0 references add reference
		add value

For failing works criterion used (P1013) may be used to express which criterion was crucial to the assessment outcome:

assessment	Riz Test edit assessment outcome fails criterion used Muslim character/s are talking about, the victim of, or the perpetrator of terrorism or extreme violence 0 references add reference
		add value

Tests following this pattern

• Landau Test
• Riz Test
• Tyrion Test

Feldman test pattern: using criterion used (P1013) and review score (P444) in case of both pass and failure

Requirements:

• The test requires a variable number of criteria to be passed and a minimum number of points to be scored

Passing and failing works follow the same model:

assessment complete assessment	Feldman Test edit assessment outcome fails criterion used no points for Feldman Criterion (a) 1 point for Feldman Criterion (b) no point for Feldman Criterion (c) criterion used 1 point for Feldman Criteria (d) no point for Feldman Criterion (e) no points for Feldman Criterion (f) criterion used 1 point for Feldman Criterion (g) missing prerequisite for Feldman Criterion (h) assessment outcome 3/10 ← maximum number of points 0 references add reference
		add value

There may be incomplete assessments with a clear result (e.g. if the minimum number of points is already scored with a subset of criteria or if it is impossible to reach the minimum number of points for the works). To make explicit that the assessment is incomplete the maximum number of points should be adjusted to the maximum number of points that could have been scored with the criteria selected.

assessment incomplete assessment	Feldman Test edit assessment outcome passes criterion used 2 points for Feldman Criterion (a) 1 point for Feldman Criterion (b) no point for Feldman Criterion (c) criterion used 1 point for Feldman Criteria (d) 2 points for Feldman Criterion (f) assessment outcome 6/7 ← maximum number of points with the criteria applied 0 references add reference
		add value

Tests following this pattern

• Feldman Test

(Afro-)BubbleGum Test Pattern: using review score (P444) in both pass and failure

Requirements:

• Out of a set of criteria one criterion has to be fulfilled
• There may be mandatory criteria

Passing and failing works follow the same model:

assessment	<AfroBubbleGum Test> edit assessment outcome passes review score 2.2/3 ← The work fulfills the mandatory first criterion. Additionally this work fulfils the second criterion out of a set of criteria of which one has to be fulfilled. 0 references add reference
		add value

Tests following this pattern

• AfroBubbleGum Test

Zimmerman Test pattern: using criterion used (P1013) in case of pass

Requirements: One criterion out of a set of criteria has to be fulfilled in order to pass the test.

For passing works criterion used (P1013) may be used in order to express which criterion/criteria is/are fulfilled:

assessment	Zimmerman Test edit assessment outcome passes criterion used Second Zimmerman Criteria 0 references add reference
		add value

For failing works no additional criterion is needed:

assessment	Zimmerman Test edit assessment outcome fails 0 references add reference
		add value

Tests following this pattern

• Zimmerman Test